Clear Air: Difficult Conversations at Work
Monday morning, investment committee. Your CIO cuts across you for the third meeting running. Nobody else seems to notice. You say nothing, make a sharp note in your pad, and spend the afternoon replaying it.
By Thursday, the story is set: He doesn't rate you. He's positioning for the next role. He always does this.
He has no idea any of it is happening.
Silent Cost
Why the conversations you avoid end up running the relationship
Most difficult conversations at work never happen. They get parked. And a parked conversation doesn't sit still. It grows a story, then a stance, then a working relationship built around the stance.
You hold back in meetings. You route around a colleague. Decisions slow down because two people have stopped really talking. Nobody puts it in the minutes, but everyone pays for it.
A clearing conversation is a short, structured way to put the issue on the table while it's still small.
Five Lines
The steps of a clearing conversation, in order and in plain words
The structure borrows from Marshall Rosenberg's work on communication and the Conscious Leadership Group's Clearing Model. Both are credited in the resources at the end. The wording below is built for a boardroom, not a workshop.
1. What happened. Only what a camera would record. "In the last three committee meetings, you started speaking before I'd finished." Not "you keep talking over me."
2. My read. Your interpretation, named as yours, not stated as fact. "My read is that you don't think my view adds much. I may be wrong." Or: "Where my head's gone with this is…"
3. How it lands. One plain word is enough. Frustrated. Concerned. Distracted. You're not confessing anything. You're giving them data they don't have.
4. My part. What you've done to keep this going. "My part is that I haven't said anything, and I've started preparing less for those meetings."
5. What I'm asking. A clear request, and what sits behind it. "Being heard on the credit view matters to me. Would you let me finish before you come in?"
Then stop. Listen. Ask what they heard, and what their read is.
The Science
Why naming the feeling and the story changes how you respond
Step three looks like the soft one. It isn't. In a UCLA study, Matthew Lieberman and colleagues found that putting a feeling into words was linked with lower activity in the amygdala. Labelling seems to take some of the heat out, which helps you stay steady enough to hear the reply.
Step two matters for a similar reason. Lisa Feldman Barrett describes the brain as a prediction machine. The story you built by Thursday is your brain's best guess from past meetings. It's not a report on this one.
Fair Warning
When clearing goes wrong, and when it's the wrong tool
Here's the uncomfortable part. Clearing models are easy to weaponise. "My read is that you're lazy" is still an accusation. It's just wearing a nicer suit.
Scripts also sound like scripts. Senior people can spot a technique at twenty paces. Read the five lines off a card and you'll get compliance, not connection. Use the structure to prepare. Then talk like yourself.
Clearing upwards carries more risk than clearing with a peer. That's not a reason to skip it. It's a reason to choose your moment, keep it short, and lead with step five sooner.
And sometimes the problem isn't between the two of you. It's an overlapping role, a decision nobody owns, or targets that pit you against each other. No amount of clearing fixes a design problem. That's a team agreement conversation, which I've written about in Start As You Mean To Go On.
Monday Morning
How to try this without making it a big event
Pick something small. A two out of ten, not a nine. Write the five lines for yourself first, and notice which one is hardest to write. That's usually the one carrying the weight.
For most leaders it's step four. Owning your part feels like giving up ground. It rarely is. It's often the line that lets the other person lower their guard.
They may not take it well. Defensiveness in the first minute is common and usually passes. What you do in that minute matters more than how well you delivered the five lines.
Knowing the lines is the easy bit. Saying them to the person who unsettles you most, and staying steady when they push back, is where the real work is.
Questions to sit with
Which conversation have you been parking longest, and what story has grown around it?
If you wrote only step one, what would a camera actually have recorded?
What's your part in keeping it going?
What would you ask for if you weren't worried about how it would land?
Where this goes next
A framework on a page is tidy. The conversation you've been avoiding isn't.
I work with senior leaders and founders in finance and tech who want to be clearer, steadier and more direct when it matters most.
Book a discovery call - 30 minutes, no pitch.
Resources
Marshall B. Rosenberg, Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life
Jim Dethmer, Diana Chapman and Kaley Klemp, The 15 Commitments of Conscious Leadership (conscious.is)
Matthew Lieberman et al. (2007), "Putting feelings into words", Psychological Science
Lisa Feldman Barrett, How Emotions Are Made
Comments